โ˜•
๐Ÿ„
MudReview
BLIND TASTE TEST โ€ข 8 BRANDS TESTED

Mushroom Coffee Taste Review

Curious about the best mushroom coffee brands? This review covers taste, mixability, and aftertaste for top options like MUD/WTR, Four Sigmatic, and more. If you want to see how mushroom coffee compares to other alternatives, check out our Coffee Alternatives A-Z guide. For a deep dive into MUD/WTR, read our Mud Water Masala Chai Review or see our MUD/WTR vs Four Sigmatic comparison.

8
Brands Tested
50+
Cups Consumed
$200+
Investment
1
Clear Winner

๐Ÿ† Taste Test Winner: MUD/WTR

After testing 8 brands blind, MUD/WTR scored highest in every category: taste, mixability, and aftertaste.

9.2/10
Overall Taste
Smooth, chai-like flavor
9.5/10
Mixability
Dissolves completely
9.0/10
Aftertaste
Clean, no bitterness
Try the Best-Tasting Mushroom Coffee - 43% OFF โ†’

Tastes like chai masala โ€ข No mushroom flavor โ€ข 30-day guarantee

๐Ÿงช Our Taste Test Methodology

๐Ÿ‘ฅ

5 Testers

Coffee lovers, health enthusiasts, and skeptics for balanced opinions

๐ŸŽญ

Blind Testing

All brands coded A-H, no one knew which was which until after scoring

๐Ÿ“‹

5 Categories

Taste, aroma, mixability, aftertaste, and overall satisfaction

โš–๏ธ

Same Prep

1 tsp powder, 8oz hot water, 2 tbsp oat milk, identical conditions

๐Ÿฅ‡ Complete Taste Test Rankings

#1
MUD/WTR
9.2/10

๐Ÿ† MUD/WTR - The Clear Winner

Taste: Remarkably smooth with warming spices. Tastes like a chai masala latte - you'd never guess it contains mushrooms. The cinnamon and turmeric blend perfectly.

Taste: 9.2
Chai-like
Aroma: 9.0
Warm spices
Mix: 9.5
Perfect
After: 9.0
Clean
Overall: 9.2
Excellent
Try Winner

43% OFF Today

#2
Four Sigmatic
7.1/10

Four Sigmatic - Runner Up

Taste: Decent coffee flavor but quite earthy. You can definitely taste the mushrooms, which some love but others find off-putting. Needs sweetener to be palatable.

Taste: 7.0
Earthy
Aroma: 7.5
Mushroomy
Mix: 6.8
Some clumps
After: 7.2
Slightly bitter
Overall: 7.1
Good
#3
Ryze
6.4/10

Ryze - Average Performance

Taste: Mild coffee flavor but chalky texture. The MCT oil helps with creaminess but there's a weird aftertaste that lingers. Better than instant coffee, but not by much.

Taste: 6.5
Mild
Aroma: 6.0
Weak
Mix: 6.8
Chalky
After: 6.2
Lingering
Overall: 6.4
Okay
#4
Laird
5.8/10

Laird Superfood - Disappointing

Taste: Very strong mushroom flavor dominates everything. If you like eating raw mushrooms, you might enjoy this. Most testers found it undrinkable without heavy sweetening.

Taste: 5.5
Strong mushroom
Aroma: 6.2
Intense
Mix: 6.0
Adequate
After: 5.5
Musty
Overall: 5.8
Below avg

Bottom Performers (5-8)

#5 Peak Performance
5.2/10 - Bitter, poor mixing
#6 Clevr Blends
4.8/10 - Gritty texture
#7 Sun Alchemy
4.1/10 - Unpleasant taste
#8 Generic Brand
3.5/10 - Avoid at all costs

Why MUD/WTR Tastes So Much Better

๐ŸŒถ๏ธ Perfect Spice Blend

The secret is in the spices: cinnamon, turmeric, ginger, and cardamom create a warming chai-like flavor that completely masks any mushroom taste.

๐Ÿ„ Premium Mushroom Processing

Their dual-extraction process removes the bitter compounds while preserving benefits. Other brands use cheap, poorly processed mushroom powders.

โš–๏ธ Balanced Ratios

Each ingredient is precisely measured. Many competitors overdo the mushrooms or under-spice, resulting in unbalanced, earthy flavors.

๐ŸŒฑ Organic Cacao

High-quality organic cacao adds richness and depth without bitterness. Cheaper brands skip this or use low-grade cocoa powder.

๐Ÿ’จ Superior Mixing

Dissolves completely with no clumps or grittiness. The particle size is optimized for smooth mixing, unlike competitors that leave you with chunky drinks.

๐ŸŽฏ Third-Party Tested

Every batch is tested for purity and potency. This ensures consistent taste and quality, while many competitors have batch-to-batch variations.

Try the Best-Tasting Mushroom Coffee - 43% OFF โ†’

Rated #1 in taste by our independent panel

๐Ÿ”ฅ Pro Tips: Make It Taste Even Better

๐Ÿฅ› Add Quality Milk

Oat milk or coconut milk adds creaminess and complements the chai flavors perfectly. Avoid dairy if you want the cleanest taste.

โœ“ Oat milk โœ“ Coconut milk โœ“ Almond milk

๐Ÿฏ Natural Sweeteners

Raw honey or maple syrup enhances the spice notes. Start with 1/2 tsp - you might not need any sweetener at all.

โœ“ Raw honey โœ“ Maple syrup โœ“ Monk fruit

๐ŸŒก๏ธ Perfect Temperature

Use water at 200ยฐF (not boiling). Too hot water can make it bitter. Let it cool for 1-2 minutes after boiling.

โœ“ 200ยฐF water โœ“ 1-2 min cooling โœ“ Better extraction

โšก Proper Mixing

Start with a small amount of hot water, mix into paste, then add remaining water. This prevents clumping.

โœ“ Paste method โœ“ No clumps โœ“ Smooth texture

๐ŸงŠ Iced Version

Make it stronger (1.5 tsp), let cool, then pour over ice with cold milk. Surprisingly refreshing!

โœ“ 1.5 tsp powder โœ“ Let cool โœ“ Add ice & milk

โœจ Flavor Boosters

Add a pinch of extra cinnamon, a drop of vanilla extract, or a tiny bit of sea salt to enhance flavors.

โœ“ Extra cinnamon โœ“ Vanilla โœ“ Sea salt pinch

Final Verdict: Don't Waste Money on Bad-Tasting Mushroom Coffee

After spending $200+ and testing 8 brands, MUD/WTR is the only one that consistently tastes great. Why settle for earthy, bitter mushroom coffee when you can have something that actually tastes like a treat?

9.2/10
Taste Score
Highest rated
100%
Satisfaction
Money-back guarantee
43%
Discount Today
Limited time offer
Get the Best-Tasting Mushroom Coffee - 43% OFF โ†’

Don't risk buying bad-tasting mushroom coffee โ€ข Get the proven winner