I spent $150+ testing Four Sigmatic's entire elixir line for 30 days. Here's my honest review of what works, what doesn't, and why MUD/WTR might be a better choice.
Four Sigmatic elixirs are decent, but MUD/WTR delivers better value, taste, and convenience. Here's why I switched after my 30-day test.
Better ingredients, better price, better taste
Good for focus but very earthy taste. Needs significant sweetening to be palatable.
Immune support is good but very expensive. Taste is tolerable with honey.
Best of their line for relaxation. Actually helps with sleep but pricey for what you get.
Energy boost is noticeable but not worth $1.35 per serving. Taste needs work.
| Comparison Factor | Four Sigmatic | 🏆 MUD/WTR | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| 💰 Cost per Serving | $1.20-$1.35 Premium pricing | $1.50 Better value | MUD/WTR |
| 🍄 Mushroom Variety | 1-2 Types Single mushroom focus | 6 Types Complete spectrum | MUD/WTR |
| 👅 Taste Quality | 6.8/10 Earthy, needs sweetener | 9.2/10 Chai-like, delicious | MUD/WTR |
| 🛒 Convenience | Complex Multiple products needed | Simple One product, all benefits | MUD/WTR |
| ⚡ Caffeine Content | 0-50mg Varies by product | 35mg Perfect balance | MUD/WTR |
| 🌿 Additional Ingredients | Limited Mostly just mushrooms | Rich Blend Adaptogens + spices | MUD/WTR |
Definitely using real, quality mushroom extracts
Lion's Mane did help with focus, Reishi with sleep
Well-designed, convenient single-serve packets
Established company with good reputation
$100+ monthly for daily use of multiple elixirs
Most need significant sweetening to be drinkable
Need 3-4 different elixirs for complete benefits
Some days worked great, others barely noticeable
One MUD/WTR bag ($45) lasts 30 days and gives you 6 mushrooms. Four Sigmatic would cost $150+ for the same benefits across multiple products.
The chai-like blend with cinnamon and turmeric masks any mushroom taste. I actually look forward to drinking it vs forcing down earthy elixirs.
Instead of buying Lion's Mane for focus, Reishi for sleep, Chaga for immunity, etc., MUD/WTR gives me everything in one perfect blend.
Better taste, better value, better results
Four Sigmatic elixirs aren't bad products, but they're overpriced for what you get. After 30 days of testing, I realized I was spending $150/month for what MUD/WTR delivers for $45.
If you're considering Four Sigmatic elixirs, try MUD/WTR first. You'll get better value, better taste, and the same (if not better) functional benefits. If you don't love it, they offer a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Better value than Four Sigmatic • 30-day guarantee • Same benefits, better price