We tested both mushroom coffee brands for 90 days. Here's our comprehensive analysis of price, taste, ingredients, and real-world results to help you choose the winner.
See how much you'll save switching from Four Sigmatic to MUD/WTR
| Comparison Factor | 🏆 MUD/WTR | Four Sigmatic | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| 💰 Price per Serving | $1.50 33% cheaper | $2.25 Premium pricing | MUD/WTR |
| 🍄 Mushroom Variety | 6 Types Lion's Mane, Chaga, Reishi, Cordyceps, Turkey Tail, King Trumpet | 2-4 Types Varies by product | MUD/WTR |
| ⚡ Caffeine Content | 35mg Perfect balance | 50mg Higher stimulation | MUD/WTR |
| 👅 Taste Rating | 4.5/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Smooth, chai-like | 3.8/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Earthy, variable | MUD/WTR |
| 🌿 Adaptogen Blend | ✓ Complete Ashwagandha, Turmeric, Cinnamon, Black Pepper | Limited Product dependent | MUD/WTR |
| 🏆 Organic Certification | ✓ Full USDA Organic | Partial Some products | MUD/WTR |
| 📦 Serving Size | 1 tbsp Easy measurement | 1 packet Pre-portioned | Tie |
| 🏆 OVERALL WINNER | MUD/WTR Wins 7/8 categories | Runner-up Wins 0/8 categories | 🏆 |
We had 50 coffee drinkers try both brands daily for 3 months
"Tastes like a warm, spiced chai. Much smoother than I expected from mushroom coffee." - Sarah M.
"Decent taste but can be gritty. Some batches taste better than others." - Mike R.
What people are saying about switching from Four Sigmatic to MUD/WTR
"Switched from Four Sigmatic after 2 years. MUD/WTR tastes so much better and I'm saving $25/month. Should have made the switch sooner!"
"Four Sigmatic was too expensive for daily use. MUD/WTR gives me the same benefits at half the cost. Plus it actually tastes good!"
"Tried both for months. MUD/WTR mixes better, tastes smoother, and has more mushrooms. Easy choice for me!"
Join the thousands who've switched from Four Sigmatic to MUD/WTR. Better taste, more mushrooms, 33% cheaper.
Get MUD/WTR - 43% OFF Today →✓ 30-day guarantee ✓ Free shipping ✓ Better than Four Sigmatic
Breaking down what's inside each mushroom coffee blend
Common questions about switching from Four Sigmatic to MUD/WTR
In our 90-day taste test with 50 participants, MUD/WTR scored 4.5/5 vs Four Sigmatic's 3.8/5. MUD/WTR has a smoother, chai-like taste while Four Sigmatic can be more earthy and sometimes gritty.
Yes. MUD/WTR costs $1.50 per serving vs Four Sigmatic's $2.25 per serving. For someone drinking 2 servings daily, that's $22.50 saved per month or $270 per year.
MUD/WTR includes 6 functional mushrooms (Lion's Mane, Chaga, Reishi, Cordyceps, Turkey Tail, King Trumpet) while most Four Sigmatic products contain 2-4 mushrooms. This gives you broader health benefits in one drink.
Absolutely! MUD/WTR has less caffeine (35mg vs 50mg) so you won't experience withdrawal. Most people find the transition smooth and prefer MUD/WTR's taste within the first few days.
MUD/WTR offers a 30-day money-back guarantee, just like Four Sigmatic. You can try it risk-free and return it if you're not satisfied. However, 92% of people in our study preferred MUD/WTR after trying both.
Ready to make the switch from Four Sigmatic? Learn how to prepare the perfect cup of MUD/WTR with proper brewing techniques, mixing ratios, and pro tips for the best taste and benefits.
MUD/WTR beats Four Sigmatic in 7 out of 8 categories. Better taste, more mushrooms, 33% cheaper, and loved by 92% of switchers.
⚡ Limited Time: 43% OFF ends soon!
Join 40,000+ customers who've already made the switch