Discover 7 delicious homemade coffee alternatives you can create with simple ingredients. Save money, reduce caffeine, and enjoy rich flavors without leaving your kitchen.
Commercial coffee alternatives can cost $15-40 per bag, but you can make similar blends at home for under $3. Plus, you control every ingredient, avoiding artificial flavors, excessive sugars, and unknown additives.
Simple kitchen tools you likely already have
From mild and nutty to rich and chocolatey
Rich, nutty flavor reminiscent of traditional coffee. Popular in Korea and Japan for centuries.
Pro Tip: Make large batches and store grounds in airtight containers for up to 6 months
Bold, slightly bitter flavor famous in French Quarter cafés. Contains natural inulin for digestive health.
Health Bonus: Chicory root supports gut health and may help regulate blood sugar
Earthy, slightly sweet flavor with potent liver-supporting properties. Perfect for morning detox routines.
Forage Tip: Harvest dandelion roots in fall when they're most potent, or buy organic dried roots
While homemade substitutes are fun and economical, nothing beats the precision of professionally crafted blends. MUD/WTR combines 6 functional mushrooms, organic spices, and adaptogens in perfect ratios you can't replicate at home.
Compare it to your homemade versions!
Adapt mushroom powder into your own blend. Supports focus, immunity, and sustained energy.
Budget Tip: Buy mushroom powders in bulk to reduce cost per serving significantly
Warming spices create a complex, satisfying flavor profile. Perfect for cold mornings and afternoon treats.
Variation: Add black tea for caffeine, or keep caffeine-free for evening enjoyment
Sweet, earthy flavor from caramelized vegetables. Rich in nutrients and naturally caffeine-free.
Sweet Note: Natural sugars from roasted vegetables eliminate need for added sweeteners
When you need something fast! Pre-made blend that dissolves instantly in hot water.
Storage: Keeps for 6 months in cool, dry place. Great for travel or office use
Cause: Over-roasting or over-steeping
Solution: Reduce roasting time by 2-3 minutes and steep for shorter periods. Add a pinch of salt to neutralize bitterness.
Cause: Under-roasting or too little grounds
Solution: Roast until deeper brown color and increase grounds ratio. Try 2-3 tbsp per cup instead of 1.
Cause: Inadequate straining
Solution: Use fine mesh strainer lined with cheesecloth or coffee filter. Let settle 2 minutes before pouring.
Cause: Variable timing or temperatures
Solution: Use timer and thermometer. Keep detailed notes of what works. Consistency is key to replicable results.
You now have 7 proven recipes to create delicious coffee substitutes at home. Start with the roasted barley recipe - it's the easiest and most coffee-like in flavor.
Try your homemade versions alongside MUD/WTR's professionally crafted blend. Many of our readers discover they prefer the convenience and consistent quality of the original, even after mastering homemade alternatives.
Get MUD/WTR + 43% OFF - Compare for Yourself30-day money-back guarantee • Free shipping over $39
Try different ratios and combinations to find your perfect blend
Calculate how much you save versus store-bought alternatives
Document your recipes and share them with fellow coffee alternative enthusiasts